Over break I have been talking to my significant other, who is also a teacher, about school philosophy. We had an interesting discussion about the line between student accountability and curriculum modification. The question was asked, "at what point do we focus on teaching students to be accountable for the work at the risk of failing if they fall behind?" and "At what point do we modify our curriculum to fit where a portion of the class is?" These are both challenging questions as a teacher.
We were discussing our frustrations in the length of the teaching time in December, and how we will fit everything in with such a short amount of time. The topic came up that some of the material was still missing in the classes. These classes are typically not as strong academically, and very low motivation. We are both combating the feeling that if we do not complete the scheduled material, in a way we are buckling under the copious complaining that we both get from these students. The complaining was especially amplified this week, while the students were on the brink of a 5-day vacation. As a teacher, I think that it is important to teach the importance of completing work, even if you do not want to do it. Some students push back in any way they can in order to avoid the completion of the workload. However, I have explained to these students that this is a life skill, and something that they will encounter after high school or college, and especially in the working world. This is where I have a serious problem ratcheting back the work in class.
But then there is the other side. At what point is the course going to start snowballing, leaving those weaker students behind? That would be equally catastrophic and also demoralizing to them. My significant other suggested the "tough love" approach, which is really just a balance of accountability but also a flexible workload. If a good chunk of the students are showing that the grasp of the material is simply not there, than it may be worth it to do some sort of encouraging activity related to the topic at hand. However, there also needs to be a system of accountability where the students take complete ownership of the work they produce, especially as juniors and seniors. This coming week we are having department meetings and I look forward to sharing this with them.